This website uses cookies to give you an incredible experience. By using this website you agree to the terms This website uses cookies, learn more ×

Label Worx

Top

 

NEWS NEWS

NEWS

Spotify Profit Payouts: What's the fairest way to recompense artists?
Posted By : Alex Powell
|
Posted Date : September 4th, 2018
The following blog comes from the CEO of the UK-based Music Managers Forum, Annabella Coldrick (pictured). She dissects the different ways that major and independent labels are distributing proceeds from Spotify share sales - and ponders what it all might mean for the lump sum coming from Facebook.

For the artist and management community, the most controversial element of Spotify's transition to a publicly traded company was how (and if) the three majors and Merlin-member labels would share the proceeds from sale of their equity holdings.

These stakes were agreed as far back as 2008. At the time, music streaming was in the earliest stage of adoption (Spotify gets a mere two mentions in the IFPI's 2009 Digital Music Report) and, although there were sensible rationale for the largest rights holders to demand equity, a lack of transparency surrounded these arrangements and the basis on which they were agreed.

We now inhabit a different world. Streaming has evolved into the record industry's dominant revenue stream (IFPI reported a 41.1% increase in streaming revenue in 2017) and Spotify the dominant global service.

The Music Managers Forum has consistently argued that, if the combined value of all repertoire/market share was used as a means to secure equity stakes, then morally it should be shared with all artists regardless of previous commercial arrangements.

In other words, the ideal scenario would be to treat these divestments as a one-off payment - from which all artists would gain. This is not, of course, a process without challenges. Essentially, we're talking about making the unattributed attributable. There's a lot to untangle.

At the MMF we understand that equity payouts are not that easy to calculate, particularly if artists and labels have changed business partners over the term the equity was held. In practice, it will likely be impossible to make distributions to everyone's agreement.

We also think it's important to manage expectations. Although the overall sums are large, when divided between thousands of artists they are unlikely to constitute a retirement fund.

However, if these deals were made on a broad-brush basis of 'market share' then, arguably, they should be returned to the widest cross-section of artists - regardless of whether they're still signed to a label, or whether they're signed to a label distributed by another label. That would seem fair to those whose music was traded for equity in the first place.

Since April, a clearer picture is now emerging of what's likely to happen. Or at least a little clearer.

So, what do we know?

Sony wrote to artist and managers in June saying they would also be sharing net proceeds of the $750m equity they have divested so far (half their holding) minus the actual costs related to acquisition and sale on a royalty basis, using an illustration of their US standard 16% royalty with deducted producer royalties.

They also employed an allocation methodology equally weighing the overall revenue and Spotify revenue to give recognition to artists on their current roster and in catalogue at the time the equity was obtained. This resulted in an allocation to nearly 100,000 eligible artists and participants with payouts beginning August 2018, and will continue as further equity is sold.

The positive news is SME won't treat this payout against recoupment and will share with all currently distributed labels (e.g. through the Orchard) who should then pass onto the artists they work with.

However, they will not pay out to labels they are no longer in business with, so will retain 100% this income. Artists signed to these labels will not receive anything.

Warner has sold their entire stake of Spotify equity for $404m and will be sharing $126m of the proceeds with artists according to their contractual terms. That means some will receive significantly more than 25%, and some a lot less - based on individual royalty rates.

Warners' calculations are based on actual consumption on Spotify over the term of the deal from October 2008-March 2018 (from not all catalogue).

WMG wrote to artists representatives in August with more detail, stating the proceeds will be credited to artists' account for the period to June 2018 as 'equity proceeds'.

However, as the share is against recoupment, much of this will go to the bottom line and remain with the label. They also are sharing payments with distributed labels, but only if this is part of the contract - so if an artist is signed to a distributed label through ADA they are likely to get nothing.

It is also unclear what then happens to the money that's not being distributed out of the artists' section of the pot when catalogues have moved on and if this is included in the $126m artist payout or not.

Universal also publicly committed to share payments in March 2018, announcing that 'consistent with UMG's approach to artist compensation, artists would share in the proceeds of a [Spotify] equity sale.' No further information has come into the public domain and it is understood none of their shares have yet been cashed in.

Merlin announced in May that it had sold 100% of its equity (estimated at over $100m). All labels that are part of the Merlin deal are seeing the equity paid across based on actual consumption on Spotify over the length of the deal.

Merlin labels can decide their own policy within the scope of WIN's Fair Digital Deals Declaration.

Beggars, Secretly and Domino have pledged to share as a minimum 50/50 of the equity proceeds with artists against recoupment - or more where the contractual split is higher.

AWAL/Kobalt are treating the equity as income like any other and paying across as a revenue share (whilst retaining 15%) based on actual consumption on Spotify during the term of their Merlin deal.

With all of these, we understand income will start to come through this autumn.

So yes, the process is complex - but it's also important, and for two important long-term reasons.

Firstly, trust.

Relationships between labels and artists, historically rather fractious, are now in the process of being realigned. Artists and managers are increasingly business partners with labels, not simply at the end of a supply chain where they sign over copyright for life. That was the old world; we're now in the new.

The majority of labels are becoming closer to service companies, while many managers now run their artist's own labels. We are frequently much closer due to these shared interests - but that also needs a shift in communication. Nobody wants to fall back into bad habits. As business partners, artists and managers should not learn of new deals via the trade press. They need information in advance.

And secondly, Facebook.

It would be easy to see Spotify as a one-off; as the last deal of its type before streaming altered the balance of the recorded business, but other unattributable deals are still being agreed. Facebook is the biggest, with over $1bn being paid for the use of music for the next two years.

Many labels are privately committing to share with artists, but again using different methodology - some using YouTube consumption, or YouTube+Spotify, as a proxy to payout in theory from this autumn.

Managers are not involved in these discussions about how this will work (even with the indies) and if we're lucky will get an email at the time statements go out explaining how the calculations have been made. Again, the policy is being decided on old-world principles of record labels being rights owners and artists and their team as content suppliers with no stake in the shape of the industry.

In the new world, we're increasingly rights partners. Artists and managers should be treated as such, with far more engagement as to how these decisions are taken and a greater understanding of what they mean
www.musicbusinessworldwide.com

 

Next Article : Former Amsterdam prison to be converted in to event space for ADE

Do you have questions?

Our team of specialists are on hand to answer all of your questions so please don't hesitate to get in contact.

GET IN TOUCH

Join Label Worx today

Signing up is quick and easy using our online form. Complete this and one of our Account Managers will be in touch.

SIGN UP TODAY

More News

Do You Want Personalised Instagram Stickers?

Our News   /   November 4th, 2019

Do You Want Personalised Instagram Stickers?

Personalised Instagram stickers can be very useful for both marketing and promotional purposes, to encourage engagement between users and content creators. But how do you make your own personalised stickers to use on Instagram? Well, we've got your back and can make them for you. Whether this is for a record label to help your brand image and consistency throughout Instagram Stories, or an artist who wants to promote a release, or maybe even to promote an event they are playing. The possibilities are endless.

Localify Aims To Put More Local Music In Spotify Users' Playlists

Industry News   /   November 7th, 2019

Localify Aims To Put More Local Music In Spotify Users' Playlists

Teams of researchers and students at Ithaca College and Cornell University have been working on a tool to inject more local music into people's Spotify playlists. It's called Localify, and works by getting people to choose their location and a selection of their favourite artists.

SoundBetter By Spotify For Artists

Industry News   /   November 4th, 2019

SoundBetter By Spotify For Artists

Find your next collaborator on SoundBetter! Looking for someone to work on your next track?

Music Industry Expected To Generate $10 Billion In 2019

Industry News   /   November 1st, 2019

Music Industry Expected To Generate $10 Billion In 2019

First-half recording revenues of the year grew 18% to $5.4 billion.

Sydney's Lockout Laws To Be Lifted In City Centre

Industry News   /   October 31st, 2019

Sydney's Lockout Laws To Be Lifted In City Centre

The laws will be lifted over five years since they were introduced. In February 2014, the city of Sydney implemented a new lockout law across the CBD.

Spotify Now Has 248m Listeners Including 113m Premium Subscribers

Industry News   /   October 29th, 2019

Spotify Now Has 248m Listeners Including 113m Premium Subscribers

Spotify has announced its latest financial results, for the third quarter of 2019. The streaming service now has 248 million monthly active users (MAUs), up 30% year-on-year, having added 16 million in Q3.

Vinyl Sales Expected To Overtake CDs for First Time In Over 30 Years

Industry News   /   October 24th, 2019

Vinyl Sales Expected To Overtake CDs for First Time In Over 30 Years

Wax is back! Vinyl sales are expected to take over CD sales for the first time since 1986.

Meet The Vinyl Fiend With One Of The Biggest Record Collections In Ibiza

Industry News   /   October 22nd, 2019

Meet The Vinyl Fiend With One Of The Biggest Record Collections In Ibiza

Game Over's Dave Browning has amassed some 10,000+ records and has the stories to explain how.

You Can Now Mix SoundCloud Tracks With Pioneer DJ's Rekordbox

Industry News   /   October 17th, 2019

You Can Now Mix SoundCloud Tracks With Pioneer DJ's Rekordbox

That's right, it's finally happening! SoundCloud's mission is to provide creators with the best tools to create and share work, and they've now partnered with major DJ apps like

ADE Guide 2019: Amsterdam's Best Record Stores

Industry News   /   October 15th, 2019

ADE Guide 2019: Amsterdam's Best Record Stores

Amsterdam's record shops are renowned in the European dance scene, crammed with cuts that have made local DJs into stars and ensured that Dekmantel festival is packed out every year. Here's a few of the best to stop off at this ADE.

New DSP: TikTok

Our News   /   October 15th, 2019

New DSP: TikTok

It gives us great pleasure to announce our latest DSP - TikTok! TikTok is the world's leader in the short-form video marketplace and is available in over 150 territories around the world. Launched by Bytedance in 2017 TikTok and it's Chinese sister service Douyin, have hit over 1 billion downloads. With a follower based system, some TikTok users have millions of people eager to see their next video, and with features such as duetting and lip-syncing, music plays a large part in the platform. This is a massive and exciting platform and one that we are delighted to be working with.

Flighthouse now has 20m followers for its first Tiktok channel

Industry News   /   October 10th, 2019

Flighthouse now has 20m followers for its first Tiktok channel

Social brand Flighthouse has reached a new milestone with its TikTok channel: it now has more than 20 million followers.

Urbanista Announces Tim Bergling Foundation Partnership To Find Mental Health Support

Industry News   /   October 9th, 2019

Urbanista Announces Tim Bergling Foundation Partnership To Find Mental Health Support

Open to Talk? Open to Listen, aims to boost the ongoing efforts in raising awareness of mental health issues.

The Electronic Music Industry Guide to Mental Health

Industry News   /   October 9th, 2019

The Electronic Music Industry Guide to Mental Health

'The Electronic Music Industry Guide To Mental Health' updates the 2016 Music Managers Forum Guide to Mental Health and has been produced alongside Help Musicians UK and Music Support.

Mexico Listens To More Music Than Anywhere Else In The World, Study Finds

Industry News   /   October 1st, 2019

Mexico Listens To More Music Than Anywhere Else In The World, Study Finds

Averaging 25.6 hours of listening per week. A new study has found that Mexico listens to more music than the rest of the world.

Spotify Users Can Now Combine Music And Podcasts On Playlists

Industry News   /   September 30th, 2019

Spotify Users Can Now Combine Music And Podcasts On Playlists

Spotify really wants its users to listen to podcasts. Starting (September 30) the streaming company has added what it describes as a 'frequently requested functionality': the ability for users to add podcasts to their own playlists.

Spotify For Artists App Redesigned For IOS And Android

Industry News   /   September 26th, 2019

Spotify For Artists App Redesigned For IOS And Android

The new app includes a refreshed design, a new 'home' tab with access to resources and updates about milestones and expanded real-time stats for new releases.

Smart Music Shopping Tips For DJs: Dig For Music With A Purpose

Industry News   /   September 25th, 2019

Smart Music Shopping Tips For DJs: Dig For Music With A Purpose

We've all been there. You buy a grip of new music that you're sure will light the dancefloor, but then when you start going through them a few days later (or, God forbid, you're playing them for the first time at a gig), they just don't have the magic that you remember them having. Some of them are downright terrible.

 

afemaudiolockc4dichewmfitnativepaypalrightstertoneden